Is a dog collar, harness, or slip lead better for walking your dog?

August 14, 2026

Share this article

As a professional dog walker, my clients often ask me, 'Should I use a collar, harness or slip lead to walk my dog?'.


But as with all things dog-related, my answer is never cut and dry as it will always depend on the dog itself.


It all comes down to your dog’s breed, activity and training levels. Plus, it needs to feel comfortable for your dog and you as their handler.


For example, if you've got an overly active dog who continually pulls on their lead when walking, you may wish to consider a harness to prevent choking, or a slip lead for training. However, if your dog is calm and trots happily beside you, a regular collar and lead would work well.


To help you decide, this handy guide will reveal the top pros and cons of each form of dog walking device.

Yellow Labrador on a leash standing on a gravel road at sunset, looking left with tongue out

A quick tip about dog walking


No matter what you choose to use, there are many benefits of taking your dog out for regular walks (daily is best!). If you find your dog is difficult to walk, it may be because they’re not comfortable with the lead, harness or collar you're using.


Sometimes, it can be trial and error (and training) to work out what works best for you and your dog.


Don't give up!

Black dog on a leash looking at the camera with mouth open against a light background

What is a dog slip lead, and how does it work?


A slip lead is designed to easily slip around your dog's neck. Once around their neck, you gently pull on the lead to tighten the loop, so it fits well. The stopper on the lead will prevent the loop from opening (so your dog can't escape you), but you do need to be able to fit 2 fingers between the lead and your dog’s neck.


The pros of slip leads for dogs


  • It's super easy to use as it slides over your dog's neck
  • It makes getting a lead on a difficult dog a lot easier
  • It's a fast and safe way to control a dog quickly (they're often used in shelters or by animal control officers)
  • They work well for dog shows as they're less noticeable and demonstrate the obedience of the dog as the handler has less interference
  • They are great for training your dog how to walk calmly on a lead (e.g. the loop tightens if they pull too much, so they learn to walk with you)


The cons of slip leads for dogs


  • Like a choke chain, if you pull too hard to correct your dog on a walk, they'll associate this with an unpleasant feeling and may start to refuse to wear the slip lead or want to go on walks
  • If they feel a tightening of the lead around their neck when they're doing something fun, like sniffing or greeting a dog or human, they may start to associate this with a negative experience
  • There's a risk of choking or gagging if they continue to pull too hard, which in turn will make them feel anxious about wearing the slip lead
  • These leads may lead to fur wearing out or risk damaging your dog's larynx, thyroid gland, arteries or nerves with prolonged choking pressure in the neck area
Small brown dog in a red harness standing on a leash on pavement

Using a regular dog collar for walking


I bet that one of the first things you bought your dog was a cute little collar. Because

of this, your dog will be used to wearing it and all you’ll need to do is attach the lead

and head outside for a walk.


But is this the best option for your dog? Let's explore.


The pros of walking your dog with a collar


  • Your dog is easy to control, which is great when you're training them
  • As your dog is likely to be already wearing a collar, they are convenient to use by simply clipping on a lead
  • Collars have a metal ring where you can attach their ID and your contact numbers (in case they happen to get away from you or escape from your yard)
  • You can choose a cool and fashionable collar to style it up when you step out for your walk


The cons of walking your dog with a collar


  • If your dog is constantly pulling, they can injure their windpipe and restrict their airflow
  • Dogs with heads as big as their necks (e.g. pugs or whippets) can slip out of a collar more easily
  • If your dog has glaucoma, eye, neck or spinal injuries, you should avoid a collar when walking as it may antagonise their injuries
  • Small toy breeds (toy poodles, chihuahuas, etc.) are best not to walk with a collar and lead due to their smaller necks and windpipes
Person walking a black-and-white dog on a leash through a grassy field

Should you use a dog harness for dog walking?


If you can't use one of the other walking devices, a dog harness may be your best option. They’re highly recommended for small dogs, or dogs with existing spinal, eye or neck conditions. They’re also brilliant if you’ve got an overly excitable dog who’s happiness to be outside makes your walk a lot more full on than it needs to be!


The pros of a dog harness for walking


  • It gives you greater control over an excitable dog
  • It fits safely and securely around your dog's body, so the pressure is dispersed over a larger surface
  • Dogs are less likely to be able to slip out of a harness, and they're less inclined to jump up when wearing a harness
  • Pulling is decreased, which helps alleviate stress on the neck and joints


The cons of a dog harness for walking


  • They take more time to fit onto your dog, which is hard if you've got an excitable dog who's keen to get out for a walk
  • Your dog may find it too bulky and uncomfortable compared to a regular collar (so they can't wear them for extended periods)
  • You usually can't attach an ID tag in case your dog escapes
  • If your dog wears a coat in the cooler months, it may be harder to fit the harness over the top
Small brindle dog looking up on a doorstep beside a glass door and doormat

Do you need a dog walker in the Glen Iris area?


If you don't have the time to take your dog out for their daily walk, I'm here to help

you. Not only can I take your dog out for a walk, but I can help you decide the best

walking device that will suit them.


As an experienced pet sitter and dog walker, I can also help you look after your

beloved animals when you're away from home. You can see all of my services here.

Booking dog walking (or my other services) is easy using my online booking form.


And here are a couple of my other blogs you may be interested in reading:


Until next time, pat your fur babies for me!

Black dog on a red leash standing in a wooded trail covered with fallen leaves.

Recent Posts

Black, white, and tan dog facing forward against a soft pink background
August 14, 2026
As a dog walker, owners often ask me if their dog needs a coat during the cooler winter months. It's a great question but one that I can't give a definite answer to! Even though we're feeling the colder air and rug up when we head outside for a walk, your dog may or may not feel the same. To help you decide if your dog needs a winter coat, let's explore why some dogs love a coat and others don't. Is a winter coat for a dog purely a fashion statement? You may have seen some dogs in your local park looking like their owners have 'styled' their pooch! The dog is flaunting a beautiful winter coat as it trots along. Pet fashion has boomed over the past few years, with many new pet parents treating their dogs as children and spending money on doggie fashion. And this may leave you thinking, should my dog wear a winter coat? Even if it's just a plain one! The answer depends on your dog's breed, size, age and coat.
Small white-and-brown dog with one ear raised, looking at the camera against a blurred background
August 14, 2026
In the animal world, August is celebrated as 'Pet Dental Awareness Month'. It's a great reminder that we need to give some attention to what's happening inside the mouths of our fur babies. Dental disease is a common issue diagnosed by vets and can start as young as two years of age. The good news is that you can do things at home to help prevent dental disease in your pet. Having 6-monthly check-ups with your vet is also recommended. They're experts at spotting the early signs of dental disease, and as a dentist does for us, your vet can perform a scale and clean on your pet if needed. Let's look deeper into dental disease and how you can help your pet.
Close-up of a sleepy brindle dog lying on a carpet, face resting on the floor.
August 14, 2026
This isn't a topic that's easy to discuss, as it's something that none of us really want to consider. Our pets are a massive part of our lives and become family members (often the ones who show you the most love!). So, deciding to euthanise your dog or cat may be one of the hardest things you'll ever have to do. Whether it's from an illness, cancer, old age or an emergency, there may come a time when it's left up to you to make the call. In an ideal world, our fur babies would live forever! Or maybe they'd magically go to sleep one night and decide to slip away on their own terms. But most pets seem to be so stubborn and resilient. And that's where you'll find that the decision to euthanise your pet will come down to you as their owner.
Four fluffy puppies peeking from a green and orange Little Tikes playhouse doorway
August 14, 2026
Deciding to bring a new dog into your life is super exciting. You've probably already spent hours scrolling through online posts, Instagram, or YouTube and getting all goo-goo over the cuteness of little puppies. But this is one of the biggest mistakes new dog owners make. They get so carried away in the excitement that they don't make a fully informed decision. When looking to find a new puppy, you need to think with your head and heart combined! Getting swept up in their cuteness is fine, but are they the right dog for you? Here's a guide to choosing a new puppy that's right for you.
Two black dogs in a Chewy.com box on a wooden floor indoors
August 14, 2026
If you're a dog owner, there's no doubt you've seen the amount of rawhide dog treats available to buy. They're featured in every pet shop, and you'll often find them as treats in Christmas dog stockings. Rawhide treats have long been promoted as a great way to entertain your dog as they chew happily for hours. And while there are some benefits of rawhide dog treats, many pet owners don't know they aren't everything they're made out to be. In this guide, you'll discover the benefits of rawhide treats, along with the hidden dangers, so you can make an informed decision on whether a rawhide chew toy is suitable for your dog. How is a dog rawhide treat made? Rawhide is made from leftovers from the leather industry (from cow hides or other animals that have been used). Here's what happens: The hide is placed in brine to help slow its decay (it still rots, but this process makes it slower). The brined hide is shipped to tanneries to strip off the fat and hair using highly toxic chemicals. More chemicals are used to puff up the hide to split the layers (the outer layer being used to make leather goods like shoes & the inner layer being used for rawhide treats, gelatin and glue). A solution of hydrogen and peroxide (and other chemicals) is used to remove the smell from the hide (as it's rotting leather). The rawhide is coloured and basted with flavours to make them look attractive. When completed, the rawhide chew is preserved with chemicals and made into shapes like rolls and bones (often using glue to hold this shape).
Brown-and-white dog with tongue out standing in a sunny green park
August 14, 2026
Some days, it's hard to believe that summer has arrived again (typical Melbourne!), but the weather experts are predicting that we're in for a hot one this year. As a dog owner, walker and sitter, I'm always very conscious of the effect of heat and sun on my pets and those I care for. And in my experience, dogs can overheat very quickly, leading to dehydration. So, as the weather is starting to warm up, I felt it was a great time to share information about dehydration in dogs – what it is, the causes, the symptoms and what to do if you spot the signs of dehydration in your dog.
Golden retriever sitting on a sandy beach at sunset, with calm water in the background
August 14, 2026
There's nothing better than a summer's day when you bundle into the car and head to the beach. Whether you're going for a walk, for fun, or just to chill out, there's something magical about the sound of the waves lapping upon the sand. And when you're heading to the beach this summer, don't forget to take your dog! Most dogs love a day trip to the beach. It's a place they can run and play, cool off and spend time with you. But, if you've never taken your dog to the beach before, there are a few things you need to know to make it an enjoyable day (for you and your dog). This handy guide will cover my top tips for keeping your dog safe on their first (or second or third) trip to the beach.
Orange-and-white cat sitting on a wooden floor in a sunlit room, looking up at the camera.
August 14, 2026
On a recent house-sitting job, I noticed that their gorgeous cat had decided to use their bathtub as a litter tray. And although your first reaction may be, 'Gross, why's my cat suddenly pooping in the bathtub?', it's important to note that this behaviour isn't overly unusual. Yes, it's frustrating, smelly, and not ideal if you're the one cleaning it up, but if your cat is pooping in the bathtub, know you're not alone! Cats are known for being meticulously tidy creatures, regularly grooming themselves to stay clean. So, if your cat has started leaving you 'gifts' in your bathtub, it's their way of telling you something's wrong in their world. Let's explore the reasons behind cats using a bathtub as a litter tray.
Black-and-white dog lying in grass with tongue out, looking to the side
August 14, 2026
With April being pet registration month (your annual registration fees are due on the 10th of April), I thought it was a good time to chat about all things pet registration. Did you know that every dog or cat over 3 months of age must be registered with your local council in Victoria? It's a legal requirement under the Domestic Animals Act 1994 . As a pet owner, it's your responsibility to ensure you register your dog or cat with your local council. And despite being fined if you don't, there are many benefits to registering your pet in Victoria, which we'll cover in this guide. Read on to discover why pet registration is essential, what to do if you've moved house, pet registration fees and how to register multiple pets in Victoria.
Gray puppy with one ear up, wearing a red collar, looking curiously at the camera
August 14, 2026
Let's chat about holidays. They're the best, aren't they? We spend so much time planning and plotting, and we get more and more excited the closer they get. You get everything organised—accommodation, airfares (sometimes!) booked, time off work and your animal's care entrusted to your family members, a local shelter or your favourite pet sitter. But what happens if one tiny part of your plan fails? I don't mean getting to the airport late and missing your plane (although that is bad!). I'm talking about the carer for your fur baby suddenly being unavailable.
Show More